On the east side of Weston Road, across from Curve Street and Howe Street, the Weston Road Community Gardens fill a cleared rectangle of the North 40. Behind them, walking trails lead past a vernal pool near Turner Road, along a boardwalk and out toward the aqueduct. Many people treat it all as a single park. The 2014 purchase did not.
When Wellesley bought the 46.76 acres from Wellesley College, the agreement required the town to keep at least half of the land as open space forever. The other half was kept available for town buildings, and the way the deal was financed shows which half was which. The garden ground on Weston Road falls on the flexible side. The trails mostly fall on the protected side. That split explains why the fire station debate this year has centered on vegetable plots and not on the woods.
Three Numbers Inside the 50 Percent Promise
The Town's North 40 history and timeline lists a $35 million purchase-and-sale price and a total property cost of $35,636,931 for 46.76 acres. The Town's fire station FAQ gives three more figures. One is a commitment and two are financing shares, so they overlap and aren't meant to add up to the whole property:
| Figure in the Town FAQ | Acres | What it describes |
|---|---|---|
| Open space commitment | 23.05 | The "at least 50%" the town committed to keep as open space in perpetuity |
| Share paid for with Community Preservation Act funds | 13.12 | The portion being protected under a conservation restriction |
| Share financed with taxable bonds | 15.75 | Borrowed this way to keep future municipal use possible |
The FAQ's 23.05 acres comes to a little under half of the 46.76 acres in the timeline's cost table, and the two documents don't explain the difference.
The middle row is the one formal protection still being worked out. About $10 million in CPA money went into the purchase, and the conservation restriction is meant to protect the CPA-funded share. The Community Preservation Committee went to the Select Board about that restriction in July, September and November 2023 and again in June 2026. In 2025 the Natural Resources Commission was unable to agree on a position statement, and talks about a land swap stalled.
The bottom row came at a cost. According to the FAQ, the taxable bonds carried a higher interest rate than tax-exempt borrowing, and the town accepted that cost so this portion would not come with the limits tax-exempt financing could have placed on future use. In 2015, Wellesley paid extra to keep about a third of the North 40 available for building.
Why the Garden Ground Is the Ground in Play
The Town FAQ says the Weston Road frontage "has consistently been contemplated for potential municipal use," and lists the ideas floated over the years: schools, recreation facilities, housing, a community center, community gardens, a land bank and solar panels.
The gardens rest on an old and limited promise. In the purchase-and-sale agreement, the town said it would endeavor to keep community gardens somewhere within the North 40 for at least three years, a commitment that never named the current Weston Road plots. It also agreed to let Wellesley College students garden on the same fees and terms as residents. The deal closed in May 2015, so that three-year period ended long ago.
The Town's own environmental reasoning also points at the gardens. Answering a question about wetlands, the FAQ says:
"The proposed station study area is partially located on the existing community-garden area, which has already been cleared and therefore may reduce the amount of new site disturbance."
Elsewhere the FAQ says the study area is focused partly on land that is already cleared and close to accessible public utilities, which can reduce new disturbance. The FAQ says the vernal pool near Weston and Turner Roads has an associated buffer area, and the master plan analysis found no wetlands or floodplain at the proposed station location.
What the Fire Station Plan Put on the Map
The fire question started on June 2, when Context Architecture presented its Fire Station Master Plan to the Select Board. The plan calls for a new headquarters to replace the century-old Station 1 in Wellesley Square and would turn the Route 9 headquarters, Station 2, into a substation. The consultant's preferred site is on the North 40 across from Curve Street, and a second North 40 option sits across from Howe Street. The Swellesley Report covered the June 25 forum, where Meghan Jop, Wellesley's executive director, estimated that a station there would take two acres of the community garden. She added that the site had not been finalized.
The Town FAQ says no precise figure has been set for the garden area that could be affected, and that a feasibility study would refine the footprint and look for ways to reduce impacts. Fire Chief Steve Mortarelli told the forum that one main reason for the project is that firefighters currently have no area separate from their living quarters for washing their gear.
The plan's less-preferred site is 515 Washington Street, next to the police station and across from the senior center. According to the Swellesley account, Glenn Remick, a town facilities project manager, said the consultant ranked it lower because an aqueduct runs through it, it allows limited flexibility later, and it is subject to Article 97, which requires legislative action for protected land.
At the Select Board's September 15 meeting, member Colette Aufranc asked for figures that would put a price on the garden: what a comparable two-acre parcel nearby would cost, what share of the North 40's value the gardens represent at today's prices, how a garden relocation or redesign could be built into the feasibility study, and how much extra the town paid for taxable bonds. She cited about 50 current gardeners and a 50-person waitlist, and asked whether the study could consider a more accessible model that serves more people. According to the meeting minutes, Mr. Largess backed studying two sites at once and raised selling part of the North 40 to pay for land elsewhere, while acknowledging that idea may be unpopular.
The Trails Sit on the Side the Deal Protected
Most of the walking routes have firmer protection. According to the Town's timeline, under the purchase terms the land between Route 135 and the Cochituate aqueduct stays wooded and natural, with no road or vehicle access within 1,000 feet of the College's Route 135 entrance. The town also agreed to try to keep the land south of the aqueduct as open space.
The fenced-off section has a separate history. Cleanup of the former town landfill was completed in November 2020 and is still monitored every year, and an Activity and Use Limitation was approved on December 7, 2020. In July, Aufranc said there are parts of the property where nothing can be done, including the old dump site and an area near the commuter rail tracks.
The walking infrastructure is newer than many people assume. The Natural Resources Commission and the CPC finished the North 40 boardwalk between July and September 2019. One guided route starts on Turner Road near the vernal pool, crosses the 500-foot boardwalk, passes the gardens and the aqueduct, and follows part of the Crosstown Trail.
Community Preservation Committee member Barbara McMahon described the gap between how the land is used and how it was bought during a Wellesley Trail Committee hike in September. "Over time, the assumption has been that it is open space, that it's just open parkland," she told The Swellesley Report, adding that it was "not the assumption" of the town that the other half would stay open space.
What the October 1 Charrette Added
On October 1, about 200 residents filled the Wellesley High School cafeteria to glue scaled cutouts of fire stations, soccer fields, housing and gardens onto maps of the property. The Swellesley Report's account describes a pitch from two ninth graders for a 5-to-7-acre bike skills park with beginner, intermediate and advanced tracks. Other ideas included a bike lane through the property to keep cyclists off Weston Road, soccer fields and the parking they would need, and plenty of gardens. One map simply said to leave it all alone.
Select Board Chair Marjorie Freiman said that "no site has been chosen" for the fire station. A recording of the session, "N40 Charrette October 1, 2026," is posted on the Town's North 40 Property page. The map exercise covered the same issue as the acreage table. Every proposal, from a bike park to a fire station, needs ground outside the protected open space, and the land along Weston Road has already been cleared.
The Dates on the Calendar
- By the end of 2026. In July, the Select Board said it aimed to vote on the North 40 conservation restriction by year-end, after gathering public feedback on options at the October meeting.
- Before a final site decision. The Town FAQ says the Select Board plans more public engagement on the fire station master plan before it chooses a site.
- Annual Town Meeting 2027. The request to fund a feasibility study was moved from fall 2026 to the spring meeting. Freiman said the town would not ask for that money any earlier.
The year-end vote concerns the CPA-funded 13.12 acres. The study of how much Weston Road frontage a station would use can't be funded until Town Meeting votes on it in the spring.
This post is general information drawn from public town documents and isn't legal advice. If you're weighing how a deed term or restriction affects a specific property, confirm the details with an attorney. At The Lara and Chelsea Collaborative, we follow these votes closely because they affect how Wellesley streets are used and valued. If you own near Weston Road or are thinking about a home near the North 40 and want to know what the conservation restriction vote or the fire station study could mean for your street, Request a Private Consultation.