An ivory shingle-style home overlooking a spacious private lawn with a mature oak and subdued late-autumn landscaping in Wellesley.

What Wellesley Builders Pay for an Old House, and What the New One Sells For

In February 2025, a single-purpose company called 78 Suffolk Road LLC paid $2,133,000 for 78 Suffolk Road, a 1955 house on a 20,241-square-foot lot. A demolition permit went in that August. In September, a new-construction permit listed an estimated building cost of $1,500,000. On August 18, 2026, the finished house sold for $5,500,000. That is eighteen months from one deed to the next.

These houses are not one-off flips. Recorded sales and town permits follow the same arc on several Wellesley streets: a builder buys an older house for about $1.1 million to $2.1 million, takes it down, and sells the new house for roughly two and a half times the purchase price. For a family comparing streets, the lesson is about the cheaper house. A 1950s house on a lot this size is priced as a building site, and the family's real competition for it is a builder who already knows the resale price.

Eighteen Months on Suffolk Road and Radcliffe Road

The second case is almost identical. Brusa Construction Corp bought 40 Radcliffe Road for $1,950,000 on April 24, 2025. The town's 2025 residential permit log describes the old house as built in 1955 on a 20,003-square-foot lot. The demolition and new-construction permits were filed the same afternoon, June 30, 2025, and the new house carried an estimated cost of $1,000,000. It sold on September 18, 2026, for $5,300,000.

The two cases share a lot of detail. Both houses were built in 1955 and both lots are just over 20,000 square feet. Each builder paid about $2 million, and each finished house sold above $5 million in the second half of 2026. Anyone can check these figures in the deed tables The Swellesley Report republishes from The Warren Group, which come from the Norfolk County Registry of Deeds, and in the town's own 2025 residential building permit log.

When a $2 million purchase turns into a $5.3 million sale this reliably, the $2 million describes the land. It does not describe the house on it.

The Same Arithmetic on Smaller Lots

Parker Road shows the same pattern at a lower price. The 2025 permit log describes 28 Parker Road as a 1929 house on an 11,000-square-foot lot. 28 Parker Road, LLC filed a demolition permit on September 8, 2025, and a new-construction permit two weeks later, with an estimated cost of $1,200,000. The new house has 5,080 square feet on a quarter acre, and it sold for $3,265,000 on September 15, 2026. Two days later, 38 Parker Road LLC sold 38 Parker Road for $3,075,000. That company had bought the property in September 2024 for $1,312,000.

Lot size alone does not set the price. Kane Built's project at 201 Lowell Road sits on the biggest lot of the group. The permit log lists a 1956 house on 27,807 square feet, a demolition permit filed in January 2025, and a new-construction estimate of $900,000. The finished six-bedroom house sold on September 30, 2026, for $3,725,000. That is well below the two Suffolk-and-Radcliffe sales on smaller lots. The street, the house a lot can hold and the buyer pool all go into the final price, and builders bid for the land with that final price in mind.

Address Old house built Lot, sq ft Builder's purchase Permit estimate for new house 2026 sale
78 Suffolk Rd 1955 20,241 $2,133,000, Feb. 2025 $1,500,000 $5,500,000, Aug. 18
40 Radcliffe Rd 1955 20,003 $1,950,000, Apr. 2025 $1,000,000 $5,300,000, Sept. 18
201 Lowell Rd 1956 27,807 Not in the tables $900,000 $3,725,000, Sept. 30
28 Parker Rd 1929 11,000 Not in the tables $1,200,000 $3,265,000, Sept. 15
38 Parker Rd Not listed Not listed $1,312,000, Sept. 2024 Not listed $3,075,000, Sept. 17

What the Permit Figure Leaves Out

It is tempting to add the purchase price to the permit estimate and subtract the total from the sale price. At 78 Suffolk that leaves about $1.9 million, and at 40 Radcliffe about $2.35 million. Neither figure is a profit. The permit estimate is the construction figure filed with the town, and a builder carries many other costs between the two deeds that show up in neither the deed tables nor the permit log. These public records can't give you a builder's margin.

What they do show a buyer is the price range. In 2025, builders paid about $2 million for these lots, and in 2026 the new houses on them sold for $5.3 million to $5.5 million. A family planning to renovate the same 1955 house is bidding against buyers who are working back from that resale range, so their offer has to reach the price builders pay for the land.

The Next Round Already Has Deeds

The deed tables from late summer and early fall 2026 show builders still buying. On October 2, 2026, 102 Suffolk Road LLC paid $2,070,000 for 102 Suffolk Road, a short walk from 78 Suffolk. In September, 42 Temple Rd LLC paid $2,040,000 for 42 Temple Road, and 17 Midland LLC bought 17 Midland Road from Wellesley College for $1,850,000. Earlier that month, Woodside South LLC paid $1,425,000 for 67 Standish Road. In early August, 62 Pine Plain Road LLC paid $1,300,000, 34 Sheridan Road LLC paid $1,250,000, Garden Path Estates LLC paid $1,275,000 for 16 Willow Road and 18 Maurice LLC paid $1,100,000 for 18 Maurice Road.

Two of those August purchases already have demolition permits. The application for 18 Maurice Road went in on October 14 and the one for 16 Willow Road on October 29, according to the town's 2026 permit log, last updated November 2. The same log lists 2026 demolitions by Kane Built at 19 Colgate Road and 10 Pinewood Circle. Applicant Fernando Dalfior, whose name also appears on the 78 Suffolk and 28 Parker permits, is listed on demolitions at 37 Martin Road, 45 Windsor Road and 28 Clovelly Road, each held by a single-address LLC.

Suffolk Road has more of these projects than any other street in the records. In 2025, Suffolk Wellesley, LLC filed for a new six-bedroom house at 66 Suffolk Road with a $1,614,000 estimate. That property had sold for $2,251,000 in January 2025. 17 Suffolk Road has a permit for a new six-bedroom, seven-and-a-half-bath house with an estimated cost of $2,361,000. With 102 Suffolk added, four Suffolk Road addresses have entered this cycle in under two years.

Why the Price Floor Holds in a Slow Fall

You might expect a slower market to soften lot prices. The current numbers point the other way. A sponsored market report on The Swellesley Report counted 49 homes for sale in Wellesley at the start of October 2026 and 14 more added during the month. In October 2025 the same counts were 58 and 19. According to the same report, pending sales volume in October 2026 was down 40 percent from October 2025, partly because there were fewer homes to choose from. It also noted that many luxury purchases are made in cash.

Fewer listings help builders. A $5 million-plus new house on Suffolk or Radcliffe faces less competition when fewer finished houses are for sale. And a builder's purchase of the next 1950s house doesn't depend on this month's pending count. It depends on what the last new house sold for, and in 2026 those sales were $5.3 million and $5.5 million.

What This Means When You Compare Streets

If a listing shows a 1950s house on about 20,000 square feet near Suffolk or Radcliffe Road in the $2 million range, look first at the lot. The builders above paid the same range for similar lots in 2025 and 2026. A family that wants to renovate and stay should expect to compete on that basis, and a higher-than-expected price on a dated house reflects the land. Our earlier posts cover the town rules that can affect the timing of a teardown, including the demolition delay bylaw and Large House Review.

Builder resales also give buyers of new homes a useful number. On these streets, a 2026 new-construction price comes with a 2024 or 2025 lot price on public record. Setting the two side by side shows what the ground under a new house sold for a year or two earlier, which helps when you set your own number. Our post on how pricing differs across Wellesley's neighborhoods covers the rest of that comparison.

Owners of an older house on a large lot have a decision to make, and deed records show what builders have paid for similar lots. Those records are public, but they are written in LLC names and permit numbers, so the comparable sales take some work to find.

Frequently Asked Questions

Where can I see what a builder paid for a specific Wellesley house? Sales are recorded at the Norfolk County Registry of Deeds. The Swellesley Report republishes Warren Group summaries of recent Wellesley sales, with buyer, seller, date and price. In the 2024 to 2026 sales covered here, many of the builder purchases were made through an LLC named for the street address.

Does a builder's purchase price mean my older house is worth the same? Not automatically. In 2026, a larger lot on Lowell Road sold as a finished new house for less than smaller lots on Suffolk and Radcliffe Roads did. A lot's value to a builder depends on what the finished house will sell for on that street.

How long does a Wellesley teardown take from purchase to resale? In the cases above, roughly eighteen months. 78 Suffolk Road went from purchase in February 2025 to resale in August 2026, and 40 Radcliffe Road from April 2025 to September 2026.

Whether you are weighing a builder's offer on a long-held house or trying to judge whether a new-construction price is fair against the lot sale behind it, The Lara & Chelsea Collaborative can pull the recorded sales for your street and go through them with you. Request a Private Consultation, and we will start with the deeds.

Work With Us

Your trusted real estate expert. We specialize in an array of properties to meet your needs.

Follow Me on Instagram